Sunday, 18 October 2015

"Fulani herdsmen Vs. farmers: Time bomb in the making."

"
Oct 19, 2015 — The Nomadic Fulanis have over the years, built up resentment among many farming communities, which have lost billions of naira worth of crops to grazing activity. Lives and property have also been lost in clashes between the Fulani herdsmen and farmers. However, the kidnapping of former secretary to the Federal Government, Chief Olu Falae by herdsmen has added a new dimension to the menace of the cattle Fulani, which has fuelled ethnic tensions and call for a permanent solution to this problem. Paul Omo Obadan examines the situation and how all citizens can enjoy their constitutional rights without trampling on that of others.

Barely two weeks after some Fulani herdsmen attacked and kidnapped the former Secretary to the Government of the Federation, Chief Olu Falae, right on his farmland in Akure, Ondo State, a group of herdsmen have again allegedly attacked and destroyed the same farm. According to the farm Manager, Bruno ‎Akhigbodemen, while conducting newsmen round the farm located at Ilado in Akure North Council area of Ondo State, over one square kilometer plantation of maize was destroyed during the invasion.

Akhigbodemen said that the Herdsmen stormed the farm with their cows and wrecked the havoc despite the horrible experience the workers and their boss had in the last two weeks sequel to their menace‎.

“Efforts by the guards to prevent the destruction of the farmland were rebuffed as they were threatened by the herdsmen until their cows grazed to their satisfaction. This incident is coming after his kidnap and payment of N5m ransom to free him from his abductors.”

The former Minister for Finance has been having a running battle with the Fulani herdsmen ‎whose cows have on several occasions destroyed his crops. The latest destruction according to findings is the fifth within two months. Before his kidnap, two Fulani herdsmen were arrested and detained for destroying over N500,000 worth of farm products. They were released after some of their leaders wrote an undertaking that they would pay compensation and would not encroach on the farm again.

Three weeks after the incident, Falae was abducted by gun wielding Fulani herdsmen on the same farmland and was released after 72 hours. This unfortunate incidence has brought to the fore, the menace of the herdsmen and the need to deal with the issue promptly before it spirals into an ethnic conflagration.

It is has also brought to the front burner the lacuna of tolerance amongst the various ethnic groups in the country. In this case, the Fulani herdsmen from the Northern part of Nigeria.

Herdsmen have over the years contributed their quota to the economy of Nigeria. The place of Fulani herdsmen is inevitably important as they have sustained the production and sale of meat in markets across the country.

However, despite this positive inclination, their activities in recent times leave much to be desired, according to reports. The conflict between the Fulani herdsmen and the farmers usually arise when the former invade community farmland with their cattle and let them graze unrestricted both on cultivated and uncultivated land thereby destroying valuable food and cash crops, which are the mainstay of the host communities. When the communities try to resist them and request their exit, the Fulani herdsmen become violent and attack the community. Armed with sophisticated weapons, including AK 47 rifles, they usually attack their target communities at the time they are most vulnerable such as at night or on Sundays when they are in their churches, killing people with impunity, mostly women and children, burning houses and looting properties. The Middle Belt has been the worst hit with communities in Plateau, Nassarawa and Benue states suffering a heavy toll in human lives and property.

The history of the Fulani encroachment on private land in Northern Nigeria tells a story of bitter conflict down the years, especially between the unwelcome guests and the Tivs on the Plateau. There is the story of how the Fulanis would leave many of their animals to graze all over the rich valleys and hillsides of the plateau, at the beginning of each season, while they wandered away with the rest to seek pasture in other parts for more greenery, to the consternation of the landowners. On their return, the nomadic herdsmen would simply gather their cattle, which would meanwhile have grown fat, and be on their way.

The Tivs then devised a plan to deal with their unwanted guests. They simply ate many of the cows and sheep that were left behind at the beginning of the season and waited for the owners. When the Fulani herdsmen returned for their cattle at the end of the season, the Tiv looked them straight in the face and blantantly confessed, “Munchi.” That is, “We have eaten them.”

This resulted in several conflagrations with the Tivs being victorious since they had the home advantage and were themselves steeped in a culture of warfare. The Fulani hardly gave up but spread their search for grazing fields to other parts of the country like Kwara State. From Kwara, they spread their tentacles to the South-West and South-East.

Most worrisome is the brutality and impunity with which the herdsmen operate without regard for the law and the sanctity of life coupled with the inability of the Nigeria Police to defend the victims mercilessly slaughtered in their homes.

According to a Public Analyst and strategist, Ayodeji Taofik Sobulo, it is unfortunate that this level of criminal impunity is happening in a sovereign state with a constitution, which declares that the security and welfare of the citizens shall be a major responsibility of the state.

“I think our government should do more in the area of security and protection of lives and properties not only in affected areas but also all over the country.

The government must urgently summon the political will to forge a lasting solution to the Fulani herdsmen and farmers clashes to prevent its escalation into tribal wars and to avert further loss of lives and property.

The FG must as a matter of priority reposition the intelligence agencies, the police to stop the attacks, killing and wanton destruction of property by the Fulani militia and retaliatory attacks by the victims. They need to be arrested, disarmed, prosecuted and jailed if guilty while their sponsors should be smoked out and brought to justice,” he said.

There pertinent questions begging for answers. Is there a clandestine agenda of the herdsmen? Who are those arming the Fulani herdsmen to unleash mayhem on innocent and defenseless Nigerians? Why are the police incapable of protecting the farmers from violent attacks by Fulani herdsmen? Is it true that they are better armed and sometimes out-number the police? Why is it difficult for the Federal Government to contain the terror of the herdsmen? Why is it that the Fulani herdsmen alleged to be behind the inhuman killings and destruction of property in the affected states and indeed across the country always get away with their crimes without being brought to justice?

Analysts believe that there is certainly grave danger ahead because some of the ethnic nationalities incessantly attacked by the Fulani militia have warned that if the government fails to protect them, they are left with no other choice than to form their own militia to defend themselves and their land from the marauders.

Yoruba leaders give red card to Fulani herdsmen

For instance, Yoruba leaders have been spitting fire and brimstone against the backdrop of the abduction of Chief Olu Falae. Prominent Yoruba leaders rose from an emergency summit in Ibadan, the Oyo State capital a fortnight ago and handed a red card to Fulani herdsmen in the South-West.

The leaders, who include President of Yoruba Council of Elders (YCE), General Adeyinka Adebayo (rtd), who was a former military governor of the defunct Western Region; Chairman of pan-Yoruba socio-cultural and political organization, Afenifere, Chief Ayo Adebanjo amongst others. They all frowned at the abduction of Falae and described it as unacceptable to the Yoruba race. In the communiqué read to reporters by Dr. Kunle Olajide, Yoruba leaders sought an end to grazing in Yoruba land and directed all nomadic herdsmen to wind up their activities in the region. Failure to adhere, according to them, may lead to a breakdown of law and order.

The communiqué also demanded immediate arrest and trial of culprits involved in the kidnap of Falae, adding that those found culpable in the alleged killing and torture of farmers on their farmlands by the herdsmen should be dealt with accordingly.

“The return of the herdsmen to his farm on Monday, October 6, 2015, to continue their mindless grazing is to us an open declaration of war on the Yoruba people by these invaders. The summit was not unmindful of the fact that the ordeal of Chief Falae is a continuation of the series of attacks these herdsmen have inflicted on our farmers over the years in their contempt for our land and the people therein, which now appears to mean nothing to them than a grazing reserve,” the communiqué read in part.

However, in a reaction to the statement by the Association of Fulani Chiefs of South West Nigeria and Miyeti Allah Cattle Breeders Association of Nigeria, MACBAN, that banning nomadic cattle rearing as proposed by Afenifere is a violation of 1999 Constitution.

Afenifere Chieftain, Yinka Odumakin described the Fulini leaders’ position as absurd and inconsiderate. He insisted that the South West has had enough of the marauding activities of the Fulani herdsmen which must end.

He said: “The Cattle Rearers Association quoting the constitution and other treaties to justify the violation of our people by the Fulani herdsmen is quite absurd and very inconsiderate. Do those laws they quoted abolished the rights of our people at the appearance of herdsmen? If they insisted nomadic grazing is a way of life for the Fulani, why are they not doing it on their soil since the north has the biggest land mass?

“We insist that we have had enough of the marauding activities of the Fulani herdsmen on our land, he said.”

However Sunday Mirror findings dug out a twist to the whole imbroglio as a native Yoruba and Professor of Islamic studies in the Department of Religions, Lagos State University, (LASU), Is-Haq Akintola said that the various ethnic groups are still not integrated in the country.

According to him, “Some of us in the South have this dogma about the North/South dichotomy and we believe everything from the North must be bad. And instead of accommodating people from the North, we are hostile. This may have formed the background for what is happening presently.”

He also said that the abductors of Chief Olu Falae are not the Fulani herdsmen. “I don’t want us to make that mistake of believing that Fulani herdsmen were the ones who came to kidnap Chief Olu Falae for two major reasons. One, they have never been known to be involved in kidnapping. And two, it was a ploy by the kidnappers to keep the police away from their trail and send them on a wrong trail. And the kidnappers actually succeeded.

Also incensed by the vituperations of the Yoruba leaders, the National President, Arewa Youth Consultative Forum, AYCF, Alhaji Shettima Yerima, who spoke to Sunday Mirror in a telephone chat said the utterances of the South-West leaders to say the least, is unpleasant and capable of plunging the nation into unnecessary crisis. Yerima also noted that the position of the pan-Yoruba group was an embarrassment and disappointment to the North.

His words: “It is unfair and unfortunate. I am working and collaborating with leaders of Fulani herdsmen from all over the geo-political zones of the country to find a lasting solution to the imbroglio. Very soon, we will come out with a communiqué,” he said.

A public affairs commentator, Mr. Olubodun Yusuf, however said the only way to forestall this is to stop the proliferation of arms in the country and if I may tell you something, during the election we all saw a large amount of arms on our streets and after the elections where have they all gone to, some for robbery, cultism, land grabbing and other nefarious activities and this include our borders. Sometimes ago, a military man was slaughtered on the long bridge going to Ibadan by this same herdsmen and till date nothing was done.

We need adequate security in all parts of the country and the government can introduce what we have in Lagos, (Neighbourhood Watch) all over the country. This is how the dreaded Boko Haram sect started in Nigeria and because the government of the day then was not ready to nip it in the bud, it has festered to a monster that we are struggling to curtail, and if care is not taken we will lose our grip on the Fulani herdsmen.



Clashes threat to peace and unity

Barrister Emmanuel Nwaghodoh, is a Staff Attorney with Social and Economic Rights Center (SERAC), an NGO that protects the social and economic rights of Nigerians.

He argued that the clashes between the Fulani and farmers is another major threat to the peace and unity of this country.

“It started some years back and people seem not to realise where they are coming from and how far they are going. Few years back now, it has become a serious threat not just among the Western states but all parts of the country. Even recently, the kidnap of the elder statesman has also been attributed to the activities of Fulani herdsmen. The government needs to see it as a serious security threat and begin to put in motion machinery on how to curtail the activities of the Fulani herdsmen.

I see it as a task that is beyond the state governors. I am looking at a situation where the Federal Ministry of Agriculture begins to put in place designated grazing areas in some states. It could be in the six geo-political zones. So that even if they migrate from the North, and come to the South, instead of moving from one community to the other destroying people’s crops, they just move straight to the designated grazing ground and begin to raise their cattle there.

Since they are mainly from the North, northern governors should also do more to also curtail the incessant movement. I know that five states in the North could take care of all the grazing of all the cattle in this country. But if they feel five states is not enough that each state in the North including also the Middle Belt should set up areas for grazing to minimize their movement from the North to the South,” he said.

However, the last administration of former President Goodluck Jonathan budgeted N100 billion to begin the first phase of the resettling of the herdsmen. What has become of that plan or the project? The resurgence of kidnapping and other forms of insecurity show that Nigeria still has a long way to go, in making the country safe. The situation should be checked before it spins out of control.

They should be checked and seek other modern ways to feed their cows.

A stitch in time saves nine.

Reverend Ayo-Oluwa Ogunyemi, Chairman LACOMFOR, said “The Yorubas should not be tempted into waging reprisal attacks against their assailants in order to safeguard their lives, properties and territories. The mantra of this administration is change.

“One of the changes I want to see is the difference in the way the Fulani nomads earn their livelihood

The Federal Government already has enough of inherited security challenges to cope with which are yet to be resolved. And so these criminal elements within the Fulani herdsmen fold should be put in checked before their activities become another inglorious national phenomena. It should not be allowed to snowball into another security storm where some unscrupulous politicians can profit from as the case may be with the Boko Haram issue now.

Frankly speaking, while the Yorubas duly recognise the Fulani herdsmen as their fellow countrymen and brothers, however the criminal elements among them, who have constituted themselves into social menace should be flushed out after scrutiny/ due process without further delay."
http://nationalmirroronline.net/new/fulani-herdsmen-vs-farmers-time-bomb-in-the-making/

Sunday, 11 October 2015

Ranch Your Cattle To Save Nigeria From More Bloodshed!

"Fasehun Tasks Yoruba To Fight Fulani Herdsmen"

"Founder of the Oodua Peoples Congress (OPC) Frederick Fasehun, has asked the Yoruba race to rise and fight the menace of Fulani herdsmen even as he described the destruction of Chief Olu Falae’s farm in Akure by cattle belonging to Fulani herdsmen as an embarrassment to the Yoruba race.
Fasheun's admonition came on the heels of a second attack on the farm of Chief Falae, a former Secretary to the Government of the Federation, which was destroyed approximately two weeks after the herdsmen kidnapped him and detained him in the bush until a ransom was paid. Falae was released after four days in the den of the abductors, an experience he described as "hell".
Fasehun, spoke at the Yoruba Summit in Ibadan on Thursday, stressing that Yoruba’s patience with the Fulani herdsmen, who he accused of killing and raping their hosts, had been exhausted. He therefore called for a radical approach to curb the deadly activities of the herdsmen.
“We can no longer continue to preach patience when our guests are disrespecting our territorial integrity. As it is, the territorial integrity of the Yoruba race is at risk. This is the time for the Yoruba people, especially the youth, to stand up and defend their nation.
“We do not have to depend on the Fulani herdsmen cattle when we have goats and chicken here. If it is confrontation, we are prepared to confront these people. Enough is enough.
“These killing, kidnapping and raping by these people on our land must stop. When violence confronts violence, we will achieve peace. We have been preaching peace for 55 years but peace has not been sustained,” he said.
Although he maintained that there was still room for dialogue, Fasehun said the visitors must learn to live with their hosts in Yorubaland.
He stated, “I believe in dialogue but it must have an end. In Oyo State during Lam Adesina era, the present President of the country, Muhammadu Buhari, came to Ibadan to complain to the governor that his people, the Fulani herdsmen, were being confronted by the indigenous farmers.
“Now that Buhari is the President, the Fulanis had the courage to traverse the entire land space from the North to kidnap Falae in a corner of Nigeria. How much patience do you want 50 million Yoruba people to have again? Nigeria belongs to all of us. The invasion must stop. We should inform those who are violating the integrity of our people to stop.”
At the event, which was attended by prominent Yoruba elders, leader of the OPC, Gani Adams, blamed the invasion of the Fulani herdsmen on disunity in Yoruba land.
He said, “We lost Yoruba unity because we disregard the strength of our language. We only react, we are never prepared. The issue is beyond Falae; unless we address it quickly. We must put politics aside and we must restructure Nigeria on the basis of true federalism.”
- See more at:
Founder of the Oodua Peoples Congress (OPC) Frederick Fasehun, has asked the Yoruba race to rise and fight the menace of Fulani herdsmen even as he described…
firstafricanews.ng

Saturday, 10 October 2015

Fulanis not relenting, more dangers ahead for Nigerian farmers:

Oct 10, 2015 — "Falae, grazing fields and herdsmen’s logic: In their response to the controversy raging over the abduction by suspected Fulani herdsmen of former Secretary to the Government of the Federation, Olu Falae, and the destruction of a part of his farm, the umbrella association of Fulani herdsmen (Miyetti Allah Cattle Breeders Association of Nigeria or MACBAN) spoke animatedly of unspecified African Union and Economic Community of West African States charters guaranteeing the free movement and grazing of cattle within and across international borders. A MACBAN spokesman and Sarkin Fulani of Lagos, Mohammed Bambado, put the herdsmen’s case succinctly: “Need we remind our brothers (Afenifere) of the African Union and ECOWAS charters that give people and animals, particularly livestock, free movement within and across international borders of West African states. Such calls and actions are in direct breach of a number of international treaties and obligations regarding the free movement of persons and animals.” Yoruba leaders on Thursday rose in defence of Chief Falae and called for the expulsion of herdsmen from the Southwest if they would not desist from their destruction of farmlands and other criminal activities. For the first time in many decades, they have hinted of self-determination.

However, countering the threat of expulsion, Alhaji Bambado argued: “Banning the movement of cattle from one part of Nigeria to another also violates the constitution of Nigeria on the freedom of movement of people and livestock. It also amounts to ethnic profiling of the nomadic Fulani.” At least three spokespersons of MACBAN addressed the press on the call by some Yoruba groups for the government to curb what they described as the herdsmen’s harmful economic and destabilising activities. All three acknowledged that frictions between farmers and herdsmen had become an issue, but their recommended panaceas were as contrastingly weak as their assertion of their rights remained adamantly strong. They suggested that everyone, including the government, must join hands to rectify the problem. One of the MACBAN spokespersons, and Sarkin Fulani of Abeokuta, Mohammed Kabir, offered a curious view of the problem. Said he: “We have appealed to the Federal Government and state governments in the Southwest to help create grazing reserves. It is done in many advanced countries. When these things don’t exist, the herdsmen have to encroach for survival…God forbid that we will be importing all our cattle from overseas like our cars. This cattle rearing creates jobs for thousands if not millions of people. There is ranching in advanced countries but we can’t be ranchers because we can’t afford it.”

While stoutly defending the rights of their members, the herdsmen offered no definite position on the rights of farmers whose crops the cattle destroy. In the opinion of Alhaji Kabir, If grazing fields would not be created, then the cattle would graze where necessary to survive. It is this dangerously myopic view of economic essentials that is at the bottom of the fierce rivalry between farmers and herdsmen in many parts of Nigeria. If herdsmen would do anything to survive, farmers would also deploy all their resources to protect their crops. Just as animal husbandry is the life of herdsmen, farming is also the life of farmers. Where the rights of herdsmen end, the rights of farmers begin. If farmers would not hold the country to ransom, it is incomprehensible that herdsmen should hold the country to ransom. Both farmers and herdsmen are after all engaged in private economic activities. The activities may be different in scope and orientation, but they remain essentially private businesses. And if herdsmen think it logical to engage in self-help because the government is lax in providing grazing reserves, farmers would sooner than later also embrace self-help, as some restive parts of Nigeria are showing. But this zero-sum game could yet prove lethal for everyone, even as the government continues to feign ignorance of the national security implications of the clashes.

Chief Falae was abducted by suspected Fulani herdsmen late September and released injured and bedraggled after payment of ransom some three days later. Before his abduction, he had had clashes with herdsmen, which the law enforcement agencies could neither resolve nor prevent. About two weeks after his release, herdsmen again provocatively grazed in his farm and destroyed a vast portion of it. Once more, the police were both helpless and frustrated. Clearly, Chief Falae would be right to feel his livelihood was being threatened. Not only was his life threatened in his own community during the abduction, he is now being forced out of business. While the abduction saga lasted, the crime was dangerously morphing into ethnic conflict, with Fulani herdsmen painted as aggressors who understood nothing but force, a replay of the sanguinary conflict laying Plateau State waste. Rather than see both the abduction and destruction of farmland of a notable Yoruba leader as capable of fuelling ethnic distrust and acrimony, the government’s response has been tame. The response went no further than tasking the police with the rescue of Chief Falae, a task carried out desultorily and opportunistically.

The suspicion is that the government is sadly and inexplicably unable to appreciate the terrifying dimensions the abduction saga could assume. Faced with a lot of security challenges in the North, Southeast and South-South, most of them inherited from inept leaders, the Buhari presidency is demonstrating virtually the same aloofness and incapacitation. Even the so-called Goodluck Jonathan national conference was unable to adequately address the problem of herdsmen/farmers conflict. It left the matter in suspended animation. The South believes northern governments should bear responsibility for livestock business and truck their products to the South for sale, while the herdsmen think it is everybody’s business. As the Secretary, Association of Fulani Chiefs in the South-West, said, if other countries could create ranches, Nigeria should not be an exception.

With Boko Haram stubbornly carrying out desperate and random attacks in the Northeast thereby making the region unsafe, and the Movement for the Actualisation of the Sovereign State of Biafra (MASSOB) spoiling for war in the Southeast and independence, the last thing the Buhari presidency needs is a destabilised Southwest. So far, the federal government has not demonstrated the capacity to judge the brewing herdsmen/farmers conflict in the Southwest as a potential and grave threat to national security. After the release of Chief Falae, the police were insensitive to suggest they would probe the traumatised family for paying ransom. Worse, other than giving the Inspector-General of Police (IGP) the marching orders to rescue Chief Falae, the president did not deem it fit to pay a visit to the Yoruba leader and elder statesman, an occasion the president would have used to make far-reaching policy statements on the country’s widespread and incessant herdsmen/farmers conflict.

President Buhari must tackle the problem urgently. He will unfortunately be proceeding from an obviously weak position as a Fulani man who had once, as a patron of MACBAN and former head of state, intervened on behalf of cattle breeders in a dispute between herdsmen and farmers in Oyo State during the governorship of Lam Adesina. But he can rise above the fray. For, as president, it is assumed he is now mature, wiser and patriotic to dispense justice and see every citizen as his responsibility. His oath of office at least assumes that he is capable of fairness and equity. The herdsmen’s view that Southwest states must create grazing reserves for cattle breeders is hardly tenable. Also, the argument that if there are no grazing lands, then cattle."

http://thenationonlineng.net/falae-grazing-fields-and-herdsmens-logic/